Blade vs. Mallet Putter – Which One Is Best For You?

Blade vs Mallet putter

The age-old debate of blade vs. mallet putter continues to intrigue golfers across the globe. With weekend warriors and avid players alike seeking an edge on the greens, understanding the key differences between these two styles is essential for making an informed decision.

In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into blade vs. mallet putter for high handicapper and discuss the pros and cons of each design.

Furthermore, we will explore factors that should be considered when choosing a putter and ultimately help you determine which type – blade or mallet – best suits your individual putting stroke and preferences.

 

What is a Blade Putter?

What is Blade Putter

A blade style putter, also known as an Anser-style putter, is a traditional golf club designed specifically for putting on the green.

Blade putters have been a favorite among golf purists for many years with their classic and minimalist design. To help you make an informed decision, this section will explore the features and advantages of blade putters.

 

Features of Blade Putters

Features of Blade

  • Narrow Head: One of the most distinguishing characteristics of a blade putter is its slim head shape. This allows for more precise control over ball contact and direction when compared to mallet style putter.
  • Toe-Weighted Balance: Most blade putters are toe-weighted or have perimeter weighting around their heads, which provides a better feel during strokes and helps with alignment issues that some players may face.
  • Straight Shaft: Typically, these types of clubs come with straight shafts that offer consistent performance across various playing conditions due to their minimal offset design.

 

Benefits of Using Blade Putters

The following are some advantages associated with using blade-style putters in your golf game:

  1. Better Feel: Many weekend golfers prefer using blades because they provide excellent feedback on each stroke thanks to their slim profile and solid construction materials like steel or carbon fiber inserts found in high-end models.
  2. Precision Control: The narrower head size allows players greater precision when striking the ball, improving accuracy on short-range shots, especially under pressure situations such as breaking long-distance par-saving attempts into manageable segments.
  3. Classic Look: Blade putters have a timeless and elegant appearance that many golfers find appealing, making them a popular choice for those who value aesthetics in their equipment.

 

Blade putters offer a combination of precision control, a better feel, and a classic design that can be an excellent choice for weekend golfers looking to improve their short game.

Nevertheless, personal tastes and preferences can be a significant factor in selecting the ideal club for each golfer.

Blade putters are generally used by more experienced golfers who prefer a smaller head and less forgiveness, while the mallet head design offers more stability for those with an inconsistent stroke.

 

Key Takeaway: Blade putters are traditional golf clubs designed for putting on the green. They have a narrow head shape, toe-weighted balance, and straight shafts that offer a better feel, precision control, and classic look to weekend golfers looking to improve their short game. However, individual preferences play a significant role in determining which type of club best suits each player.

 

What is a Mallet Putter?

What is a Mallet Putter

A mallet putter is a golf club designed with a larger, more rounded putter head shape than the traditional blade putter. Mallet putters tend to offer several benefits for golfers looking to improve their putting game. In this section, we will explore the key features and advantages of using a mallet putter on the green.

 

Key Features of Traditional Mallet Putter

Benefits of mallet

  • Larger Head Size: The clubhead size is the most noticeable difference between mallet and blade putters. Mallets have significantly larger heads that provide increased stability during your stroke.
  • Higher Moment of Inertia (MOI): Thanks to their larger size, mallet putters generally have higher MOI than their blade counterparts. A higher MOI means better resistance against twisting when you strike off-center shots, improving accuracy and consistency.
  • Better Alignment Aids: Many modern mallet designs come with various visual aids that help golfers line up their shots more accurately. These can include lines or shapes on top of the clubhead or even integrated sightlines within its body.
  • Different Weight Distribution: Unlike blade models where weight tends to be evenly distributed throughout, many putter manufacturers strategically place additional weight in specific areas like perimeter weighting systems to enhance forgiveness on mishits.

 

The Benefits of Using a Mallet Putter

Moving beyond just appearance differences, there are some notable performance advantages associated with using a mallet head-style putter as well:

  1. Improved Forgiveness: As mentioned earlier, mallet putters’ higher MOI and strategic weight distribution can lead to better forgiveness on off-center hits. Even if your stroke is not spot-on, the chances of the ball following its intended trajectory are heightened.
  2. Better Distance Control: The larger head size of a mallet putter allows for more consistent contact with the golf ball, resulting in improved distance control across various putting surfaces.
  3. Increased Confidence: For some golfers, simply looking down at a larger clubhead provides a sense of confidence when standing over their putt. This mental boost may translate into better performance on the green.

 

In summary, mallet putters offer several advantages over traditional blade designs thanks to their unique shape and construction features. Golfers who struggle with consistency or accuracy during their putting stroke may find that switching to a mallet-style club could be a more forgiving putter

Mallet putters are a great option for golfers looking to improve their accuracy and control on the green.

 

Key Takeaway: Mallet putters have larger heads, higher MOI, better alignment aids, and different weight distribution than blade putters. They offer improved forgiveness, distance control, and increased confidence for golfers struggling with consistency or accuracy during their putting stroke. Switching to a mallet-style club could help improve these aspects of the game.

 

Pros and Cons: Blade vs. Mallet Putter

Pros and Cons of Blade v mallet

This section will explore the various benefits and drawbacks of blade and mallet putters to help you decide which type best fits your golf game.

Blade Putter Pros:

  • Better feel: Many golfers prefer the feel of a blade putter due to its traditional design and solid contact with the ball. This can provide better feedback on each putt, allowing for improved consistency over time.
  • Easier alignment: The simple design of a blade putter often makes it easier for players to align their shots accurately. Focusing on proper aim becomes more straightforward with fewer distractions or visual elements.
  • Variety in designs: A wide range of styles are available within the category of blade putters, making it easy for players to find one that matches their personal preferences or aesthetic tastes.

 

Blade Putter Cons:

  • Limited forgiveness: Due to their smaller size and sweet spot, blade putters are generally less forgiving than mallets when it comes to off-center hits. This means slight mishits may result in more significant consequences than a mallet-style option.
  • Potentially challenging for beginners: Some novice golfers might struggle with controlling distance when using a blade-style putter because they require greater precision during strokes.

 

Mallet Putter Pros:

  • Increased forgiveness: Mallet putters typically have a larger sweet spot and more weight distribution across the clubhead, resulting in greater forgiveness on off-center hits. This can be especially beneficial for those struggling with consistency or new to golf.
  • Better stability: The design of mallet putters often includes additional features that enhance stability during the putting stroke, such as perimeter weighting or counterbalancing. These factors can lead to improved accuracy and control over time.
  • Easier distance control: With increased mass and size, mallet-style putters may provide better distance control for some players than blade options.

 

Mallet Putter Cons:

  • Potentially overwhelming designs: Some golfers might find the visually complex designs of certain mallet putters distracting or difficult to align properly.
  • Limited feel feedback: Due to their larger size and increased forgiveness, mallet putters may not provide as much feedback on contact as blade options do. This could make it harder for players who rely heavily on feel when making adjustments during play.

 

When mulling over the advantages and disadvantages of blade versus mallet putters, it is important to think through various aspects before investing in one. However, the decision ultimately boils down to individual preferences and golfing goals; thus, one must consider several factors when selecting their ideal putter.

 

Key Takeaway: This section discusses the pros and cons of blade versus mallet putters. Blade putters offer a better feel and easier alignment but have limited forgiveness and may be challenging for beginners. Mallet putters provide increased forgiveness, better stability, and easier distance control, but their visually complex designs can be overwhelming, and they may not provide as much feedback on contact as blade options do.

 

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Putter

factors when deciding

When selecting a putter for your golf game, size, weight, feel, and more should be considered to find the ideal balance between blade and mallet putters.

These include size, weight, feel, and more. By considering these aspects carefully, you can find the right balance between blade and mallet putters that will help improve your performance on the green.

 

Size

The size of a top premium mallet putter is an essential factor to consider when making your choice. Blade putters tend to be smaller and more compact than their mallet counterparts. Therefore, if you have limited space in your golf bag or prefer a sleeker design, a blade might be better suited for you. On the other hand, if stability is what you’re after or you have no issue with larger clubheads, mallet putters may be ideal due to their larger head sizes.

 

Weight

The weight of a putter plays an important role in determining its overall feel and performance during each stroke. Generally speaking, heavier mallets provide greater stability through impact, while lighter blades offer increased control over distance and direction(source).

To determine which type suits your preferences best, try out various weights at local pro shops or demo days before making any final decisions.

 

Feel

  • Blade Putters: Known for providing excellent feedback on contact with the ball thanks to their thinner faces and solid construction materials like steel or carbon fiber(source). The feedback from the ball on contact is made easier to interpret for golfers with these putters.
  • Mallet Putters: These putters typically have a softer feel due to their larger heads and more forgiving materials like aluminum or composite(source). While this can help reduce mishits, some players may find it difficult to gauge distance control as accurately as with blade putters.

 

Alignment Aids

Alignment aids are crucial in helping you line up your putt correctly. Mallet putters often come equipped with various alignment features such as lines, dots, or other visual cues that can assist in proper setup.

Blade putter designs tend to be simpler but still offer some level of guidance through traditional sightlines on the top edge of the club head. Ultimately, choose a design that best suits your eye and instills confidence when standing over a putt.

 

Stroke Type

Your stroke type plays an essential role in determining which style of putter is most suitable for you. Golfers who have an arcing stroke generally benefit from using toe-weighted blade putters because they promote natural rotation during the swing(source).

Conversely, those with straight-back-straight-through strokes might prefer face-balanced mallets since they encourage minimal twisting throughout impact.

When choosing a putter, it is important to consider factors such as the design of the club head, shaft length, and weight, grip size, and feel. Having considered the design, length, weight of the shaft, and grip size and feel, let’s now explore which type of putter head – blade or mallet – could be most suitable for you.

 

Key Takeaway: When choosing a putter, consider size, weight, feel, and alignment aids. For example, blade putters are smaller and provide excellent feedback on contact with the ball, while mallet putters have larger heads for greater stability through impact but may offer less control over distance and direction. 

 

Which One is Best for You?

 

Selecting the ideal putter to match your specific requirements and likes can be a challenging endeavor. To help you make an informed decision between blade and mallet putters, consider the following factors:

  • Your skill level: If you’re a beginner or high-handicap golfer, a mallet putter with its larger sweet spot and higher forgiveness might suit you better. On the other hand, if you’re an experienced player with consistent strokes, a blade putter could provide better control and feel.
  • The greens on which you play: The type of greens where you usually play can also influence your choice of putter. For instance, fast greens require more touch and precision; hence a blade putter would work well here. However, slower greens demand less finesse but more power – making mallets ideal.
  • Putter weight distribution: Blade vs. Mallet Putters have different weight distributions that affect their performance on various shots. A head-heavy putter design like most blades provides stability during long-distance putting while face-balanced options, such as some mallets, are excellent for short-range accuracy.
  • Aesthetics & alignment aids: Your personal preference regarding how the club looks plays an essential role too. Some golfers find comfort in using simple designs like traditional blades without any distractions from added visual elements. In contrast, others prefer modern-looking clubs featuring advanced alignment aids found in many mallet models.

 

To determine which one is best suited for your specific requirements, we recommend trying out both types at local pro shops or get a putter fitting from a certified fitter.

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to selecting a putter – what works best for you might not work well for another golfer.

In addition, remember that practice is key. Whatever type of putter you decide upon, honing your skills and refining your technique will always be crucial in improving your putting performance.

 

Key Takeaway:  To choose between blade and mallet putters, consider your skill level, the type of greens you play on, weight distribution, aesthetics, and alignment aids. No one putter is suitable for everyone; what works well for one golfer may not be the best choice for another. Consider getting a proper putter fitting to find one you like the best. Practice is key in improving your putting performance regardless of which type of putter you ultimately decide upon.

 

FAQ: Blade vs. Mallet Putter

Is a blade or mallet putter better for a beginner golfer?

Mallet putters are generally recommended for beginners due to their added forgiveness and stability on off-center hits.

The larger clubhead and perimeter weighting can help compensate for any inconsistencies in a beginner’s stroke, providing a better chance for accurate putts. However, every golfer is different, and some beginners may find that the narrower profile and more precise feedback offered by a blade putter better suits their natural stroke or personal preferences.

The key is to test both types of putters and choose the one that feels most comfortable and instills the most confidence in your putting ability.

 

Are blade putters more suitable for experienced or beginner golfers?

Many experienced golfers prefer blade putters due to their precise feedback and control. Skilled players with a consistent stroke may find that the enhanced feel of a blade putter helps them better judge distance, pace, and green conditions.

However, there is no strict rule for which type of golfer should use which type of putter. Some experienced players also prefer mallet putters for their stability and forgiveness. Ultimately, the choice between a blade or mallet putter comes down to personal preference, putting stroke, and feel.

 

How does the weight distribution differ between blade and mallet putters?

Blade putters typically have their weight concentrated in the center of the clubhead, which can offer more precise control and feedback on well-struck putts.

 

Mallet putters, on the other hand, have more perimeter weighting, which increases the MOI (moment of inertia) and provides more stability and forgiveness on off-center hits. This increased forgiveness can be especially beneficial for golfers who struggle with consistency in their putting stroke.

 

Can my putting stroke influence the type of putter I should choose?

Yes, your putting stroke can play a role in determining the best type of putter for you. For example, golfers with a straight-back-straight-through putting stroke may benefit from the stability and alignment aids often found in mallet putters.

In contrast, those with an arcing stroke might find the sleeker design and enhanced feedback of a blade putter more suitable. However, the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference and feel, and it’s essential to try out both types of putters to determine which works best for your unique stroke.

 

Are there any notable professional golfers who prefer one type of putter over the other?

Some notable professional golfers have a strong preference for either blade or mallet putters.

For example, Tiger Woods has used a blade putter throughout his career, most notably the Scotty Cameron Newport 2, and credits the precise feedback and control as reasons for his preference.

On the other hand, Jason Day has had success with a mallet putter, specifically the TaylorMade Spider Tour, citing its stability and alignment benefits.

It’s important to remember that every golfer’s preference is unique, and you should choose a putter that works best for you based on your stroke and comfort level.

 

Can I switch between a blade and a mallet putter, or should I stick to one type?

You can experiment with both types of putters to see which works best for your game. Some golfers switch between the two depending on course conditions, green speeds, or their current form.

It’s essential to practice with both types and select the one that feels most comfortable and helps you perform at your best. Keep in mind that regularly switching between putters may affect your consistency, so once you find a putter that works well for you, it’s generally a good idea to stick with it to build confidence and improve your putting performance.

Wrapping It Up – Blade vs. Mallet Putter

Selecting the correct putter is paramount to refining your golf game, and being aware of the contrasts between blade and mallet putters can help you make an educated decision. Blade putters are traditional and offer more control for skilled players, while modern mallet putters provide more forgiveness and stability on off-center hits.

When deciding which type of putter to use, consider factors such as your putting stroke, personal preferences, and skill level. Ultimately, choosing a blade or mallet putter comes down to what feels comfortable in your hands and helps you sink those important putts.

While there will always be a blade vs. mallet putter debate, trying different types will help determine the right putter for you.

We hope you found our article Blade vs. Mallet Putter helpful. If you’re an avid golfer like us, subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest tips, reviews, and guides from Humble Golfer. Plus, you’ll be automatically signed up for our free monthly giveaway!

Amir

Amir

Amir is a passionate weekend golfer with a love for the sport. He's always testing out new gear and exploring new courses, while also constantly learning and improving his game. As a true student of the sport, he's dedicated to sharing his knowledge and experiences with other golf enthusiasts.

Leave a Reply

Stay in the loop and win big!

Join our community for exclusive monthly giveaways and stay up-to-date with the latest posts, videos, and news.

Recent Posts

At Humble Golfer, we pride ourselves on providing our readers with valuable information and resources related to the game of golf. As part of our commitment to transparency, we want to disclose that some of the links on our website are affiliate links.
This means that we may earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links. However, please rest assured that this will not affect the price you pay. Our goal is to only recommend products and services that we truly believe will benefit our readers.
We appreciate your support and trust in our recommendations. If you have any questions or concerns, please don’t hesitate to contact us. Thank you for visiting our website and we hope you enjoy the content!