Best Ball vs. Scramble: A Guide for Weekend Golfers

Best ball vs. Scramble

Welcome to our in-depth exploration of two popular golf tournament formats: Best Ball vs. Scramble.

Whether you’re a seasoned golfer looking to add variety to your outings or a newcomer seeking to expand your knowledge of the sport, understanding the key differences between Best Ball and Scramble can help you choose the proper format for your next event or simply enrich your appreciation for the game.

In this comprehensive post, we’ll first discuss each format’s rules, strategies, and nuances, comparing and contrasting their unique aspects.

You’ll learn about the distinct advantages that each format offers, as well as tips and tricks on how to excel in both game styles.

By the end of this guide, you’ll have a solid understanding of Best Ball vs. Scramble golf and be equipped to make informed decisions when selecting a format for your next golf event.

You’ll also have an arsenal of strategic tips, ensuring you’re prepared to tackle these exciting game styles confidently and skillfully. So grab your clubs, and let’s embark on our journey to mastering Best Ball and Scramble golf!


Comparing Best Ball vs. Scramble

Comparing formats

When choosing a format for your weekend golf game, two popular options are Best Ball and Scramble.

Both formats encourage teamwork and camaraderie while offering unique challenges that can help improve your overall golf skills. This section will dive into the key differences between Best Ball and Scramble formats in golf, helping you decide which is right for your next round.


Best Ball Format

In a Best Ball format, each player on a team plays their own ball throughout the entire hole. After each hole, just the lowest score from all team members is taken into account as the collective result for that particular gap.

This means that if Player A scores 4 strokes on Hole 1 while Player B scores 5 strokes, only Player A’s score of 4 would be counted towards the team’s score total.


Scramble Format

The golf Scramble format differs from Best Ball in that all players on a team hit from the same spot after selecting the most favorable shot among them.

For example, if both players hit their tee shots but one lands in an ideal position while another ends up in a sand trap or rough area, they will choose to play from where they deem more advantageous (usually closer to the green).

The ball must be one club length from the chosen ball and must be in a similar area. For instance if the ball you chose is in the rough, all other balls must be played one club length from the chosen ball in the rough.

They continue doing so until completing every hole with just one shared final result per group instead of individual tallies like before.

Key Differences Between Best Ball and Scramble

  • Individual play vs. team play: In Best Ball, each player is responsible for their own shots throughout the round, while in a Scramble format, all players contribute to a single shared result.
  • Pace of play: Generally speaking, Scramble tends to be faster than Best ball because each player takes fewer strokes as they work together towards one score per hole.
  • Skill level balance: The Scramble format can help even out skill levels among teammates since everyone’s shot contributes equally, whereas, in Best ball, stronger players may carry more weight due to lower individual scores being counted.
  • Tactical approach: Best Ball requires strategic decision-making on an individual basis (e.g., risk-taking), while Scrambles encourage teamwork and collaboration when choosing which shot or position will benefit the entire group most effectively.



Key Takeaway: Best Ball is an individual play format where only the lowest score among team members counts while Scramble encourages teamwork and collaboration to achieve a single shared result per hole.


Benefits of Best Ball

Benefits of Best Ball

The Best Ball format offers several advantages for weekend golfers and those looking to improve their game. This popular golf style provides a competitive edge and encourages teamwork and camaraderie among players.


Improved Individual Performance

Each team member can hone individual skills by playing their own ball while striving to outperform other teams. As teammates battle against other squads, they can gain insight into each other’s advantages and disadvantages while still contributing to their group’s ultimate victory.


Balanced Competition

One of the primary benefits of Best Ball is that it levels the playing field for golfers with varying skill levels.

Since only the lowest score on each hole counts towards a team plays total, weaker players’ scores are often offset by stronger teammates’ performance. This balance allows all participants to enjoy a competitive experience without feeling overwhelmed or discouraged by more skilled opponents.


Teamwork and Camaraderie

  • Collaboration: The Best Ball team format promotes collaboration as teammates strategize and support one another in achieving low scores.
  • Camaraderie: By fostering communication between teammates during play, this team format helps build lasting friendships on and off the course.
  • Motivation: When playing as part of a team in Best Ball tournaments, individuals are motivated not just by personal achievement but also by contributing towards collective success.


Faster Pace of Play

Compared to other golf formats, Best Ball often results in a quicker pace of play. Since only the lowest score on each hole is recorded, players can pick up their balls once they are out of contention for that hole. This faster pace allows more teams to participate in golf tournaments, reducing wait times between holes.



The Best Ball formats can be easily adapted to accommodate team sizes or tournament structures.

For example, two-person teams can compete in a “better ball” format, while larger groups may opt for a four-player team setup. Additionally, event organizers can incorporate various scoring systems, such as stroke play or match play, depending on their preferences.

The benefits of Best Ball can be seen in the ability to score a low number and still have fun with friends. On the other hand, Scramble offers more opportunities for team collaboration and strategy.


Key Takeaway: Best Ball is a popular golf format that encourages teamwork and camaraderie among players while improving individual performance. It levels the playing field for golfers with varying skill levels, promotes collaboration, builds lasting friendships, results in a quicker pace of play, and can be easily adapted to accommodate different team sizes or tournament structures.


Benefits of Scramble


The Scramble format can be advantageous for players of all aptitudes, providing a chance to team up and bond while allowing for speedier play.


Accessibility for All Skill Levels

The Scramble format is ideal for players with varying abilities as it allows everyone on the team to contribute regardless of their individual skill level.

Since each player takes a shot from the best position after every stroke, even beginners can participate without feeling overwhelmed or holding back more experienced teammates. This inclusive nature encourages new players to join in and enjoy the game while learning from others.


Fostering Teamwork and Camaraderie

In contrast to traditional stroke play where individuals compete against one another, Scramble tournaments emphasize collaboration among team members.

Players must strategize together when selecting shots that maximize their collective strengths while minimizing weaknesses. This cooperative approach helps build strong bonds between teammates and fosters sportsmanship by encouraging support rather than rivalry.


Faster Play Time

A significant advantage of Scrambles is that they generally result in quicker rounds compared to other formats like Best Ball or match play since teams are hitting fewer total shots per hole due to using only one golf ball instead of four separate ones (one per player).

As such, there’s less waiting time between strokes, leading to a faster overall pace during games – perfect if you’re pressed for time.


Tips For Success In Scramble Format

  • Coordinate with your partners to maximize the effectiveness of each shot based on individual strengths.
  • Take advantage of each player’s strengths, such as long drives or accurate putting.
  • Maintain a positive attitude and encourage your team members throughout the round.


Key Takeaway: Playing a Scramble format in golf has several benefits, including accessibility for all skill levels, fostering teamwork and camaraderie among participants, and providing opportunities for faster play. It is an inclusive game that encourages new players to join in while learning from others. To succeed in this format, communicate with your teammates to determine the best strategy for each shot and take advantage of each player’s strengths.


Strategies for Best Ball

Stretegy for Best Ball

When playing a Best Ball format in golf, it’s important to have a solid strategy to maximize your team’s success. This section will discuss some key strategies to help you and your teammates perform well during a Best Ball tournament.


Understand Your Teammates’ Strengths and Weaknesses

Identifying each teammate’s strengths and weaknesses can provide an effective strategy for selecting shots yielding the lowest team score.

Realizing this knowledge enables you to make prudent choices concerning which shots will probably bring about lower scores for the team.

For example, if a team member best shot is at driving while another has exceptional short-game skills, consider using their respective talents when selecting shots.


Communicate Effectively

Good communication is crucial for any successful golf team, especially in a Best Ball format where teamwork plays such an important role [source].

Make sure all players understand the rules of the competition and share insights or suggestions throughout the round.

  • Talk about club selection before hitting each shot.
  • Discuss potential hazards or obstacles on each hole.
  • Share tips on green reading and putting lines based on personal experiences from previous rounds played together or individually.


Play Smart Golf: Course Management Skills Matter.

In addition to focusing on individual strengths, smart golf course management can significantly impact overall performance during a Best Ball event. Here are some tips:

  1. Choose the right club for each shot, considering factors such as wind direction and elevation changes.
  2. Avoid high-risk shots that could lead to penalty strokes or difficult recovery situations.
  3. Take advantage of opportunities to use your teammates’ skills strategically. For example, if one player has a strong tee shot on a particular hole, let them take the riskier drive while others focus on more conservative approaches.
  4. Stay Positive and Supportive


Maintaining a positive attitude throughout the round is essential for success in any golf format but can be especially beneficial during Best Ball competitions.

Encourage your teammates when they make great shots and offer support when things don’t go as planned. A supportive team environment can help players stay focused and motivated throughout the event.

Incorporating these strategies into your game plan will increase your chances of success during Best Ball tournaments. Remember that teamwork is key – by understanding each other’s strengths, communicating effectively, managing the golf course wisely, and maintaining positivity throughout the round; you’ll set yourselves up for an enjoyable experience with improved performance.


Key Takeaway:  To succeed in a Best Ball format, it’s important to understand your teammates’ strengths and weaknesses, communicate effectively, play smart golf by choosing the right club for each shot and avoiding high-risk shots, and maintain a positive attitude throughout the round. 


Strategies for Scramble

Strategy for Scramble

Teamwork and strategy are crucial to maximizing success when playing a Scramble format in golf. This section will provide valuable tips and insights on improving your performance during a Scramble tournament or friendly match.


Selecting the Right Teammates

The first step in building a successful Scramble team is selecting teammates with complementary skills. Ideally, your team should consist of players who excel in different aspects of the game, such as driving, iron play, short game, and putting. This way, each player can contribute their strengths to the overall team performance.


Optimal Tee Shot Strategy

In a Scramble format, at least one player must hit a solid tee shot into play on every hole. To achieve this goal:

  • Have your most consistent driver hit first to ensure there’s always one golf ball safely in play.
  • If possible, choose players with varying shot shapes (draws and fades) so they can tackle different holes effectively.
  • Encourage aggressive shots from other teammates once there’s already one safe drive – this could lead to significant advantages if executed correctly.


Approach Shots: Play Smartly

Making smart decisions when hitting approach shots is vital for scoring well in Scrambles:

  • Select clubs that allow you to control distance accurately rather than focusing solely on maximum yardage potential.
  • Aim for conservative targets if no teammate has hit an excellent approach yet – remember that getting close enough for an easy putt is better than risking disaster by aiming too aggressively.
  • Analyze green slopes before hitting approaches – knowing where not-to-miss can save you from costly mistakes.


Mastering the Short Game and Putting

Scramble formats often come down to who can make the most putts, so it’s essential to have a strong short game:

  • Communicate with your teammates about green breaks and speed – sharing information will help everyone putt it more effectively.
  • Have your best putter go last – this way, they’ll have multiple reads on each putt before making their attempt.
  • Practice various types of chip shots in advance – executing high-lofted flop shots or low-running bump-and-runs is crucial for getting up and down during Scrambles.


Teamwork and communication are essential for a successful Scramble team, but incorporating strategies to make the experience more enjoyable will greatly enhance your chances of success. Remember that teamwork and communication are key components in any successful Scramble team.


Key Takeaway: To succeed in a Scramble format, it’s important to select teammates with complementary skills and have at least one player hit a solid tee shot into play on every hole. Making smart decisions when hitting approach shots and having a strong short game are also crucial for scoring well in Scrambles.


FAQ: Best Ball vs. Scramble

Can Best Ball and Scramble formats be combined?

Yes, some tournaments combine the Best Ball and Scramble formats in a single event, often called a “Shamble.”

In this hybrid format, players follow the Scramble format off the tee, selecting the best drive and playing their next shot from that position. From there, each player completes the entire hole individually, and the team records the best score among its members for that hole.


How are handicaps factored into Best Ball and Scramble tournaments?

Handicaps can be incorporated into Best Ball and Scramble formats to level the playing field and ensure fair competition.

In Best Ball, each player’s handicap is taken into account when calculating their net score for each hole. In Scramble, teams are typically assigned a single team handicap based on the average handicap of its members or a percentage of the combined handicaps, which is then applied to the team’s final score.


What is the ideal team size for Best Ball and Scramble tournaments?

In Best Ball, teams usually consist of two, three, or four players. In Scramble, teams are typically composed of four players. However, both formats can be adapted to accommodate different team sizes, depending on the event’s specific rules and objectives.


How long does it take to play a round of Best Ball or Scramble golf?

The duration of a round of Best Ball or Scramble golf depends on factors such as the number of players, the size of the field, and the speed of play.

Generally, a round of Best Ball takes about the same time as a traditional round of individual stroke play, while a round of Scramble may take slightly less time due to the reduced number of shots played by each team.


Can beginners participate in Best Ball and Scramble tournaments?

Absolutely! Best Ball and Scramble formats suit golfers of all skill levels, including beginners.

In fact, these formats can be delightful for novice players, as they provide an opportunity to learn from more experienced teammates and contribute to the team’s success without the pressure of playing every shot.


Are Best Ball and Scramble formats suitable for charity and corporate events?

Yes, both Best Ball and Scramble formats are ideal for charity and corporate events, as they promote teamwork, camaraderie, and networking opportunities.

These formats are more inclusive than individual stroke play, allowing players of varying skill levels to participate and contribute to their team’s performance.


Wrapping It Up – Best Ball vs. Scramble

After comparing Scramble vs. Best Ball , it’s clear that both formats have their unique benefits and strategies. Best Ball allows players to focus on their individual game while still contributing to the team score, whereas Scramble encourages teamwork and can lead to some impressive shots.

Players should prioritize consistency and avoid taking unnecessary risks to succeed in Best Ball. In Scramble, communication is key for deciding which best shot call to use and executing it effectively as a team.

We hope you found our article Best Ball vs. Scramble helpful. If you’re an avid golfer like us, subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest tips, reviews, and guides from Humble Golfer. Plus, you’ll be automatically signed up for our free monthly giveaway!


Picture of Amir


Amir is a passionate weekend golfer with a love for the sport. He's always testing out new gear and exploring new courses, while also constantly learning and improving his game. As a true student of the sport, he's dedicated to sharing his knowledge and experiences with other golf enthusiasts.

Leave a Reply

Stay in the loop and win big!

Join our community for exclusive monthly giveaways and stay up-to-date with the latest posts, videos, and news.

Recent Posts

At Humble Golfer, we pride ourselves on providing our readers with valuable information and resources related to the game of golf. As part of our commitment to transparency, we want to disclose that some of the links on our website are affiliate links.
This means that we may earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links. However, please rest assured that this will not affect the price you pay. Our goal is to only recommend products and services that we truly believe will benefit our readers.
We appreciate your support and trust in our recommendations. If you have any questions or concerns, please don’t hesitate to contact us. Thank you for visiting our website and we hope you enjoy the content!